HOME   |   ABOUT US   |  CONTACT US   |  SUPPORT US 

The Art Story Resource on Modern Art
Join Our Facebook Group  
Follow us on Twitter 
Join Our Mailing List
Stay informed
on the latest
news, exhibitions
and events in
modern art.
Movements in and related to Abstract ExpressionismArtists in and related to Abstract ExpressionismCritics and Historians related to Abstract ExpressionismGalleries, Museums, Schools and Influences related to Abstract Expressionism Current Events and Exhibitions related to Abstract Expressionism


Abstract Expressionism Theory: Art for Art's Sake
TEXT SIZE PRINT PAGE
QUICK VIEW:

Introduction to Art for Art's Sake
The concept of "Art for Art's Sake" rejected the idea that the success of an artwork could be measured by its representational accuracy or the effectiveness with which it conveyed some form of narrative or intrinsic message. Instead, it implied that an art object was best understood as an independent and self-sufficient creation. Most commonly associated with abstract painting and sculpture of the mid-20th century, artwork that embraced the notion of art for art's sake communicated no distinct message to the viewer other than existing purely as an aesthetically pleasing work, and one that organized color and line into a formally satisfying whole.

Breakdown of Basic Ideas
  • Art that existed for its own sake is autotelic, from the Greek term autoteles, which means "complete in itself."
  • The artwork served no function â€" utilitarian, political or otherwise â€" other than to exist as a work of art.
  • This concept is inextricably tied to Formalism, which implied that art was judged on its value; the value of art for art's sake was measured solely on its formal qualities of line, color, composition and texture.
DETAILED VIEW:

Origins of Art for Art's Sake
The actual term "Art for Art's Sake" came from the French expression l'art pour l'art, a philosophy that maintained that art should contain no subjective pursuit or function other than to please the viewer. The writer credited with coining the term l'art pour l'art was French poet and literary critic Théophile Gautier, who studied with and worked alongside Manet, Baudelaire and Balzac.

Gautier's phrase later became something of a battle cry within French bohemian culture during the mid-19th century. For most academic artists of this time, plying their trade was an opportunity to celebrate certain ideals that were not intrinsically connected to concepts concerning art, such as mankind's moral values, the beauty of nature, and Christian sensibilities. These forms of art existed first and foremost as didactic messages of a political, social, or religious nature. "Art for Art's Sake" was a way for artists to rebel against this academic mode of thought, and to create art that had value simply as a work of art in and of itself, and not as a means to convey a moral message.

Art for Art's Sake and Abstract Expressionism
In New York City following the end of World War II, several artists living in the bohemian community of Greenwich Village began experimenting with pure abstraction as a way to bring painting back to a fundamental language of pure form. These actions were perceived in the art world as a manner of rebellion from the Marxist influenced Social Realist style in which artists used their paintings to convey a specific political and/or social message.

Pure abstraction, for the most part, denounced the use of all subject matter, and its practitioners strove to be released from the bourgeois tyranny of conveying meaning and purpose. Artists like Hofmann, Pollock, Motherwell, Rothko and Newman all created abstract art that, by design, contained no didactic message whatsoever and only represented the artist's spiritual relationship with the canvas.

Parallels with Media Purity
The concept of media purity parallels art for art's sake. When a work of art that was produced in a pure medium and maintained a visual balance of formal elements, it was made for its own benefit, not to champion any political cause or moral value. Critic Clement Greenberg believed that medium purity was best understood through works of absolute abstraction and plastic representation. Such artworks served no other purpose than to be paintings that are pleasing to the eye and achieve a visual balance.

Criticism of Art for Art's Sake
"Art for Art's Sake" has been criticized by numerous theorists and critics, chiefly by those who adopted a Marxist perspective for deconstructing art. The Marxist and anti-Fascist philosopher Walter Benjamin, in his 1935 manifesto, "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," referred to l'art pour l'art as "a theology of art. This gave rise to what might be called a negative theology in the form of the idea of 'pure' art, which not only denied any social function of art but also any categorizing by subject matter." In the manifesto's epilogue, Benjamin again derided l'art pour l'art as a form "self-alienation [that] has reached such a degree that it can experience its own destruction as an aesthetic pleasure of the first order. This is the situation of politics which Fascism is rendering aesthetic. Communism responds by politicizing art." In Benjamin's view, the concept of art for art's sake had the potential to be morally destructive, because without a political message, art lost its sense of authenticity. Art for Art's Sake, according to Benjamin, was a self-serving exercise on parallel with Fascism.

Another opponent of "Art of Art's Sake" was African novelist and literature professor Chinua Achebe, who once expressed the belief that it is an inherently Western and Eurocentric practice to create art with no higher purpose or association. Achebe's criticism, however, is far from Benjamin's Marxist/Socialist objection. In a 1985 interview Achebe said, "An artist in my view is always afraid of extremists' he is always afraid of those who claim to have found the ultimate solution to any question … That is precisely why an artist will never get into any rigid association. Even if he is in such an association, you will find him saying things that are quite strange for that association." These associations referred to anything political, moral, religious or otherwise. It was not the responsibility of the artist to infuse his art with a politically charged message, but the artist was nevertheless obliged to have at least some opinion, otherwise the artwork was merely a hollow object.

IMPORTANT WRITINGS:
By Oscar Wilde
Published in 1891
    Key Points:
  • Oscar Wilde offered that the artist who could completely isolate himself from the outside world and produce great art, like Keats and Flaubert, was the exception to the rule. Most men, according to Wilde, were emotionally compelled by the social plights around them. "The emotions of man are stirred more quickly than man's intelligence," wrote Wilde, implying that emotion cannot be avoided in the act of creation.
  • Wilde continued to explain that, "…the moment that an artist takes notice of what other people want, and tries to supply the demand, he ceases to be an artist, and becomes a dull or an amusing craftsman, an honest or a dishonest tradesman … Art is the most intense mode of individualism that the world has known. I am inclined to say that it is the only real mode of individualism that the world has known." This individualism, according to Wilde, was what set the common man apart from the true artist.
  • Although Wilde never explicitly used the term "Art for Art's Sake" in his essay, he identified the Renaissance as the time when such a concept took shape. "One might point out how the Renaissance was great, because it sought to solve no social problem, and busied itself not about such things, but suffered the individual to develop freely, beautifully, and naturally…" This absence of any social involvement was what defined the sense of individualism in the artist.

By Clement Greenberg
Published in Partisan Review, 1939
    Key Points:
  • In the section of the essay devoted to the avant-garde, Greenberg detailed the steps in which the avant-garde artist emigrated from bourgeois society to bohemia. "…once the avant-garde had succeeded in 'detaching' itself from society, it proceeded to turn around and repudiate revolutionary as well as bourgeois politics." This was a seminal moment in modern art history since, according to Greenberg, art's true significance was no longer socially or politically revolutionary in any way. This raised the question: what makes it important?
  • "In turning his [the artist's] attention away from subject matter of common experience," wrote Greenberg, "the poet or artist turns it in upon the medium of his own craft." The craft, or medium of the artwork itself, was what made the avant-garde culturally relevant. As abstract art was coming to the New York art world's attention in the late 1930s, pure abstract form connoted no clear revolutionary ideal, but appeared revolutionary in itself.



Quotes
"Let us not any longer be ensnared by the siren songs of 'culture,' 'broadmindedness,' 'art for art's sake.' There is only one culture - the proletarian culture, the culture of the Free Man."
- Martin Ahern, excerpted from the magazine The Young Worker, August-September 1922

"... the avant-garde poet or artist sought to main the high level of his art by both narrowing and raising it to the expression of an absolute in which all relativities and contradiction would be either resolved or beside the point. 'Art for art's sake' and 'pure poetry' appear, and subject matter or content becomes something to be avoided like a plague. It has been in search of the absolute that the avant-garde has arrived at 'abstract' or 'nonobjective' art - and poetry too..."
- Clement Greenberg, excerpted from "Avant-Garde and Kitsch"

"Works of art, in my opinion, are the only objects in the material universe to possess internal order, and that is why, though I don't believe that only art matters, I do believe in Art for Art's sake."
- E.M. Forster


Content written by:
  Justin Wolf



We need your donation to maintain and grow The Art Story. Click here to help us.


MAJOR WORKS:
Artwork Artwork Artwork